🎙️ This Week on The Cold Cases Podcast with Dustin & Amanda
Episode Recap: Adam Rosenthal, Tupac Shakur & the Alcatraz Escape 🕵️♂️🎧
Welcome back to another thought-provoking episode of The Cold Cases Podcast, where Dustin and Amanda explore some of the strangest, darkest, and most baffling true crime cases ever documented. In this week’s episode, the duo dives into three explosive topics: a fallen Gainesville politician turned killer, the enduring mystery of Tupac Shakur’s death, and the legendary Alcatraz escape that still haunts law enforcement to this day.
🔪 Case 1: Adam Rosenthal – From Gainesville Mayor Hopeful to Double Murderer
Dustin kicks off the episode with an unsettling personal connection.
“I actually met Adam Rosenthal years ago. I remember thinking he was weird but polite. Never expected this kind of ending…”
Rosenthal was once a Gainesville mayoral candidate who mysteriously vanished. Rumors swirled about his mental state, cult involvement, and sudden disappearance. He was presumed dead for some time.
Then, shockingly — Rosenthal was discovered alive in a remote area and arrested for the murder of two people. 😱
🧩 What Amanda & Dustin Discuss:
Rosenthal’s bizarre personality and alleged cult involvement 🌀
How his sudden disappearance led to assumptions he was deceased
The dramatic reveal when he was found alive and linked to two homicides
The implications for Gainesville politics and mental health awareness 🧠
Questions about what happened during the time he was “missing”
Whether cult ideology or psychosis played a role in the murders
Amanda adds:
“It’s terrifying to think someone can disappear, be presumed dead, and then return as a killer. Like, what happened in that gap? Who was watching him? Who wasn’t?”
Both agree this story is less about politics and more about mental deterioration, power, and secrecy.
🎤 Case 2: The Death of Tupac Shakur – Murder or Master Escape?
The second segment dives into one of the most discussed cold cases in pop culture history: the murder of Tupac Shakur. 🚘💥
Tupac was gunned down in Las Vegas in 1996 after a Mike Tyson fight. He was hit four times and died six days later in the hospital. Despite countless theories, no one was ever officially convicted. 🤯
🎧 Podcast Talking Points:
A breakdown of the most popular suspects:
Orlando Anderson (Crips affiliate)
Suge Knight (Death Row Records CEO)
The FBI (due to his activist influence)
The mysterious behavior of people around Tupac the night he was shot
How some people believe Tupac faked his own death 😮
New evidence that’s emerged in recent years, including unreleased letters
The 2023 arrest of Duane “Keffe D” Davis and what it might mean
Why this case still has a grip on public imagination
This portion ends with a discussion on how Tupac’s death parallels other famous unsolved murders — and how sometimes justice just doesn’t catch up. ⏳
🏝️ Case 3: The Alcatraz Escape – Lost at Sea or Secret Survival?
The third and final segment focuses on the 1962 Alcatraz escape, one of the most infamous prison breaks in U.S. history. Three inmates — Frank Morris, John Anglin, and Clarence Anglin — escaped from the maximum-security prison and were never seen again. 🏃♂️💨
The FBI declared them drowned. But over the decades, strange clues emerged suggesting they may have survived. 👀
📬 What Dustin & Amanda Explore:
How the inmates used spoons and raincoats to dig through cell walls and build a raft 😳
The official belief that they drowned in San Francisco Bay 🌊
A 2013 letter sent to law enforcement allegedly from John Anglin, stating he survived and wanted to negotiate a deal
Photographs and sightings of men resembling the Anglin brothers in Brazil 🇧🇷
The 2018 forensic age-progression photos released by the FBI
Why law enforcement quietly reopened the investigation
Amanda says:
“The fact that this letter was even sent is wild. Either someone’s playing a long con... or those men actually made it out and vanished.”
Dustin adds:
“This case is the ultimate prison break story. And if they survived? It changes everything we thought we knew about Alcatraz security.”
This story sparked an emotional conversation about freedom, perseverance, and how some mysteries refuse to stay buried.
The Cases This Week We Covered in This Episode
🕵️ Become a Citizen Detective with TheColdCases.com 🧠🔍
Are you fascinated by unsolved mysteries?
Do you read between the lines and question the official story?
Then it might be time to become a Citizen Detective. 🕯️✨
At TheColdCases.com, we believe that everyday people can make a difference — not by interfering with investigations, but by becoming informed, ethical, and organized advocates for truth. Become a Citizen Detective today!
📘 Our $20 PDF Guide Includes:
✅ How to research cold cases effectively (databases, news archives, timelines)
✅ How to file FOIA requests to unlock government records 📂
✅ Tools for organizing case files like a pro (digital & physical systems)
✅ Interview templates & ethical boundaries when contacting families
✅ Tips on social media advocacy without spreading misinformation
✅ Mental health tips for researchers who dig deep into dark content 🧠💛
Whether you're just getting started or want to level up your investigative skills, this guide is made for you. It’s easy to follow, actionable, and grounded in real investigative principles. 👣 Get the Citizen Detective PDF Training today!
Share this post