🕵️♀️ The Springfield Three: Vanished Without a Trace
Three women. One summer night. Zero answers.
On June 7, 1992, Springfield, Missouri, became the center of one of America’s most baffling missing persons cases. Known as The Springfield Three, this case has haunted investigators, journalists, and families for over three decades. The victims—Sherrill Levitt, her daughter Suzie Streeter, and Suzie’s best friend Stacy McCall—disappeared without a trace from a quiet suburban home. 😢🏡
Despite thousands of leads, national media coverage, and decades of speculation, the mystery of what happened to them remains unsolved. Let’s break down the timeline, explore theories, and remember the victims in this haunting case. 🕯️
👩👩👧 Who Were the Springfield Three?
🧑🎓 Suzie Streeter (19)
Recently graduated from Kickapoo High School
Planned to attend beauty school
Described as bubbly and outgoing
Lived with her mother, Sherrill
👩👩🏫 Sherrill Levitt (47)
Suzie’s mother
A single mom and hardworking cosmetologist
Recently purchased her home on Delmar Street
Known for her dependability and quiet lifestyle
👩🎓 Stacy McCall (18)
Suzie’s best friend
Also a new high school graduate
Planned to spend the night at Suzie’s after graduation festivities
They were happy, full of life, and excited for the next chapter—until that fateful night. 🎓💔
📆 The Timeline: What Happened That Night?
🎉 June 6, 1992 – Graduation Night
Suzie and Stacy attended a few parties to celebrate their high school graduation 🥳
They originally planned to sleep over at another friend’s house but decided instead to stay at Suzie’s
🌅 June 7, 1992 – Early Morning
By 2:00 AM, the girls arrived at Suzie and Sherrill’s home at 1717 E. Delmar Street
No signs of trouble were evident at that time 🏠
🕛 Morning
Around 9:00 AM, Stacy’s mother, Janis McCall, tried to reach her daughter by phone but got no answer 📞
She went to the house later that morning and found:
All three women’s cars in the driveway
Purses, makeup, and keys inside the house
A broken porch light
No signs of forced entry
Sherrill’s dog, Cinnamon, agitated but unharmed
There were no obvious signs of struggle, yet the three women had vanished. 😨
🧐 Initial Investigation Missteps
Janis McCall and friends entered the home before police arrived—a crucial mistake that may have compromised key evidence. 👣
The bed appeared slept in
Cigarettes were still in ashtrays
Suzie’s clothes were folded neatly
All phones, including a cordless one, were oddly missing
A strange message was left on the answering machine, but it was accidentally deleted
Police quickly realized this wasn’t a runaway situation. The women were gone... and it wasn’t voluntary. 🚫🧳
🧩 Theories That Refuse to Die
With such an eerie and clean disappearance, theories started swirling. Here are the most talked-about ones:
1️⃣ Random Abduction Gone Wrong
Some believe a stranger was watching the house and took the women by surprise. 😱
Maybe the girls were followed from the party
The broken porch light may have played a role
Why take all three? And how without noise?
🧠 Criticism: No screams were heard, and the abduction would have taken precision.
2️⃣ Targeted Hit or Known Offender
Could someone have known the women and used that trust to get inside? 🤔
Suzie had a past with troublesome exes
Sherrill may have overheard something dangerous at work
Some neighbors claimed to see suspicious vehicles that night 🚐
🧠 Criticism: Still no solid link or confession has ever emerged.
3️⃣ The Robert Craig Cox Theory
Convicted kidnapper and suspect in other disappearances, Cox once claimed he knew where the Springfield Three were buried. ⛏️
He was in Springfield at the time
Gave inconsistent stories
Later recanted but said they’d “never be found”
🧠 Criticism: He’s known for attention-seeking and has never provided proof. 📉
4️⃣ Buried Under a Parking Garage?
In 2007, a tipster told journalist Kathy Baird the women were buried beneath a Cox Hospital parking lot. 🏥
Ground-penetrating radar found anomalies
Police refused to dig, citing lack of evidence
🧠 Criticism: It’s been over 30 years—if they’re there, why no action?
🧪 Modern Forensics: Still No Breakthrough
Despite the rise of forensic technology and genetic genealogy breakthroughs, The Springfield Three case has not benefited from any significant physical evidence. 🧬
No DNA
No bodies
No crime scene
No verified witnesses
It’s as if they simply vanished into thin air. 🌫️
📰 Media Coverage & Pop Culture
The case has been featured in:
People Magazine Investigates
Disappeared (ID Channel)
Countless podcasts and YouTube deep-dives 🎙️📺
It remains one of the most-covered missing persons cases in American history, largely because of the bizarre, crime-free crime scene. 🔍
💔 The Impact on Families
Janis McCall has never stopped searching for her daughter Stacy. 🕊️
She founded One Missing Link, a non-profit supporting families of the missing
She worked with the National Center for Missing Adults
She keeps Stacy’s memory alive through billboards, interviews, and local events
🧡 “I’ll never give up,” Janis once said in an interview. “Because someone knows something.”
🚫 What We Still Don’t Know
Were the women abducted by one person or more?
Why was there no struggle or noise?
Was the message on the answering machine important?
Could they really be buried somewhere under the city?
The unanswered questions continue to haunt Springfield. 😔
👁️ A Look at the House Today
The house on Delmar Street still stands. It has changed owners, but for many locals, it’s a ghostly reminder of a summer morning that never made sense. 🏚️
🕊️ Remembering the Victims
Let’s never forget the three women at the heart of this case. 💐
✨ Sherrill Levitt
A devoted mom and respected stylist who built a life for her daughter. Known for her quiet strength and kindness.
✨ Suzie Streeter
A funny, fashionable, and warm-hearted young woman. Always smiling, always laughing.
✨ Stacy McCall
Bright, responsible, and excited about her future. Loved by her classmates and her community.
🔦 Can You Help?
Someone knows what happened that night. 💡 If you have information, you can contact:
Springfield Police Department
📞 (417) 864-1810
🌐
https://www.springfieldmo.gov
🧠 Final Thoughts: Why This Case Matters
The Springfield Three represents every family’s worst nightmare: going to bed and waking up to the impossible. No alarms, no warnings, no clues. 🕳️
This case stands as a chilling reminder of:
The importance of preserving crime scenes 🧼
The heartbreak of families who never stop hoping 🧡
The resilience of communities that refuse to forget 🏘️
If we keep their stories alive, maybe—just maybe—someone will come forward. 👁️🗨️
📢 Want More Deep Dives Like This?
Subscribe to TheColdCases.com for weekly articles, updates on missing persons, and exclusive access to our Citizen Detective PDF guide 🕵️♂️📘
🧩 Every clue matters. Every voice counts
Share this post