The Cold Case of Hayden Manis: The System Failed Him

A Cold Case That Should Never Have Happened

The Disappearance of Hayden Manis: A Cold Case That Should Never Have Happened

Want to be a Citizen Detective? Get our PDF on investigating cold cases at home!

On February 6, 2025, an alarming press release from the Delaware County Sheriff’s Investigation Division in Muncie, Indiana, reignited attention to a case that should have never gone cold. The subject was Hayden Manis, a young child who had been missing for over five years. The announcement raised urgent questions: How could this have happened? Why had Child Protective Services (CPS) failed to ensure his safety? And most troubling of all—how could a child disappear without anyone noticing for so long?

A Troubled Beginning

To understand the tragedy of Hayden Manis, we must go back to 2016. That year, both of Hayden's parents lost custody of him after drug tests revealed they had been using cocaine. That same year, police found Hayden and his father, Dustin Manis, in a motel room strewn with heroin. It was a grim scene that demonstrated clear parental negligence. In response, the Indiana Department of Child Services (DCS) stepped in and placed one-year-old Hayden with his grandfather, Gary Manis.

Gary, whom Hayden affectionately called "Paw Paw," became his guardian, providing the stability and care the child desperately needed. But this period of safety was short-lived.

The System Fails Hayden

Within just a year and a half, Dustin Manis completed the necessary court-ordered probation, drug treatment, and counseling. Despite his history of relapse and substance abuse, the court granted him custody of Hayden once again. Hayden's grandfather, who had grown incredibly close to the child, objected vehemently, arguing that Dustin was not fit to be a parent. However, his protests fell on deaf ears. The courts and the DCS, prioritizing procedural checkboxes over genuine child welfare, returned Hayden to his father.

Gary was never given a formal opportunity to present his concerns in court. His pleas were ignored, and his worst fears soon became a reality.

The Disappearance

The last known sighting of Hayden was at a Christmas gathering at his great-grandmother's home in Muncie. His grandfather vividly recalls that moment, cherishing what would unknowingly be his final memory of his grandson. After that holiday, Hayden seemingly vanished.

For years, there was no word of his whereabouts. Questions arose, but few answers were provided. How could a small child disappear, and why did no one notice? It wasn't until February 2025, when 13WRTV News published an investigative piece, that the case began gaining public attention.

Delaware County Prosecutor Eric Hoffman admitted that Hayden’s disappearance haunted him daily. During an interview with 13 Investigates, Hoffman was pressed with a fundamental question: "How can a little boy just disappear, and no one knows where he is?" His response underscored the chilling reality:

"There are very few ways that an adult can vanish—they can flee the country, they can disappear on a bender in Las Vegas. But children? Kids Hayden's age don’t just go anywhere on their own. There are only a few ways a child can disappear, and none of them are voluntary."

This stark truth raised another disturbing question: why had this case remained in the shadows for so long? Why hadn't communities across Indiana been informed about Hayden’s disappearance?

A Broken System

A central point of failure was the Indiana Department of Child Services. CPS had an obligation to follow up on Hayden's well-being, especially given his father's troubled history. Yet, it appears they failed to conduct routine welfare checks or raise red flags when they lost track of the child.

By the time authorities finally turned their attention to Hayden’s case, it was far too late. His father, Dustin Manis, died of a drug overdose on September 5, 2024. He took to his grave the truth of what happened to his son. With no leads and no one left to provide information, the mystery of Hayden’s fate remains unresolved.

Seeking Justice

Hayden’s case stands as a grim testament to systemic failures that put vulnerable children at risk. From the courts to child protective services, the agencies responsible for safeguarding him instead facilitated his return to danger. Now, the community and law enforcement must come together to uncover what really happened.

The search for Hayden continues. Authorities urge anyone with information to come forward. No lead is too small, and every detail could be crucial in bringing closure to this tragic case.

Contact Information for Tips:

- Delaware County Sheriff’s Office, Indiana - (765) 747-7885

- DCPO Sheriff’s Office Investigative Division - (765) 747-7881

- National Center for Missing & Exploited Children - 1-800-THE-LOST

- Crime Stoppers of Central Indiana - (317) 262-TIPS

For those who want to help keep Hayden’s memory alive and demand answers, there are numerous advocacy groups dedicated to missing persons:

- Missing and Not Forgotten

- Missing & Murdered: Searching for the Truth

- Disappeared and Still Missing!

- Mary's Safe Haven for the Missing

- Keeping Kids Safe

- Missing from Indiana & Unsolved Murders

Final Thoughts

The tragedy of Hayden Manis is a call to action. No child should be lost due to negligence, and no family should be left searching for answers alone. The failure of multiple agencies to protect him must be acknowledged, and reforms must be demanded.

Somewhere, there are answers waiting to be uncovered. It’s time to find justice for Hayden. His story cannot be another statistic—it must be a wake-up call.

If you liked this article, you’ll love Inside The Mind of a Serial Killer.