The Chilling Cold Case of Terri and Nathan Schlatter

Vanished Without a Trace

Apr 18, 2025

Want to be a Citizen Detective? Get our PDF on investigating cold cases at home!

In the quiet town of Wagoner, Oklahoma, a haunting mystery still lingers in the air—a mystery that has remained unsolved for over three decades. The disappearance of a young mother, Terri Schlatter, and her one-year-old son, Nathan, continues to shake the community and bewilder investigators. 😢💨

Though the world has changed since 1993, the heartache and unanswered questions remain painfully fresh for the family of Terri and Nathan. This case, steeped in suspicion, emotional trauma, and legal complexities, reminds us that not all tragedies receive the justice they deserve. ⚖️💔

🌅 The Day Everything Changed: March 21, 1993

Terri Schlatter, just 26 years old, was a woman caught in a storm of stress and legal drama. On the morning of March 21, 1993, she was scheduled to testify in a federal court case involving her estranged husband, Darrell Schlatter. The charges? Bank fraud. 🏦⚖️

That morning, Darrell and Terri reportedly dropped off their baby boy Nathan at a babysitter’s home. This was not unusual—they were preparing for a tense day in court. But by the time the sun had set, something was clearly wrong. 🌇💔

Darrell returned to the babysitter’s house alone. He told the sitter they no longer needed her services. Terri? Nowhere to be seen. From that moment on, no one would ever see Terri or Nathan again. 😨🕳️

🚨 Missing: A Mother and Her Baby

At first, there was hope that maybe Terri had simply run off, maybe out of fear, maybe to protect her child. But that hope would soon be replaced by grim realizations. 🌫️😔

Terri’s family, especially her sister Kerri Yingst, knew immediately that something was very wrong. “She would never leave without contacting me,” Kerri said in a public statement. “Never without telling someone where she was going.” 📞💬

The relationship between Terri and Darrell was rocky. According to family members, Terri had spoken of being afraid of Darrell. The federal court case in which she was scheduled to testify involved him. The implication was chilling—Terri might have been silenced. 🤐🔇

🧩 Darrell Schlatter: The Only Suspect

Darrell was swiftly identified as the only person of interest in the case. He was the last known person to see Terri and Nathan. He had motive—Terri was set to testify against him in a bank fraud investigation. 💸📉

What made the case more frustrating was that Darrell was not immediately charged with anything related to their disappearance. Law enforcement didn’t have enough physical evidence—no bodies, no witnesses, no surveillance. Just suspicion and fear. 😠🕵️‍♂️

Then, just a few months later, Darrell Schlatter was found dead in his jail cell. He had taken his own life while in custody for the bank fraud case. 🪦💀

His death only complicated matters. Without him to question, the investigation hit a massive roadblock. If he had answers about what happened to Terri and Nathan, he took them to the grave. 🕳️🧠

🌾 A Ranch Full of Secrets?

One of the most disturbing elements of the case involves the large rural property where Darrell worked. According to reports, the land he had access to was expansive—acres of wide-open fields, wooded areas, and ponds. 🏞️🌲

Terri’s family has often expressed concern that Darrell could have used this land to conceal any evidence. With so much open space and rural isolation, anything could have happened, and the chances of discovery were slim. 😨🚜

Despite search efforts, no sign of Terri or Nathan has ever been found—not a single piece of clothing, no personal belongings, and tragically, no remains. It's as if they vanished into thin air. 🧳🚫

😢 A Sister’s Lifelong Mission

Terri’s sister, Kerri Yingst, has made it her mission to keep the case alive. She manages a Facebook page titled “Schlatter and Child Nathan Missing and Endangered”, where she regularly posts photos, memories, and pleas for information. 🖼️🙏📱

“This case isn’t cold to us,” she’s said. “It’s still burning in our hearts.” ❤️‍🔥

Kerri and her family believe strongly that someone knows something. Whether it’s a friend of Darrell’s, a former coworker, or even someone in the community who overheard something—there is always the chance that a single piece of information could finally bring answers. 🧠💬

📂 The Struggle of Cold Cases

The Schlatter case highlights many of the issues that plague cold cases across the country. According to the National Institute of Justice, more than 250,000 unsolved murder and missing persons cases remain open in the U.S. 😳📊

Some of the challenges include:

Lack of physical evidence 🧬
Fewer or unreliable witnesses 🧑‍🤝‍🧑❌
Death of the primary suspect 💀
Time erasing memories and clues 🕰️

When the primary suspect dies early on, as in this case, it significantly hinders the investigation. Law enforcement is left with speculation, limited forensics, and frustrated families. 😩🚫

🔍 Could Forensic Technology Help?

In recent years, technological advancements have reignited some cold cases. From genetic genealogy to cadaver dogsand ground-penetrating radar, there's renewed hope for solving even the oldest mysteries. 🧬🐶📡

Could this be the case for Terri and Nathan?

Possibly. If new tips come in, the authorities might be able to re-explore the areas Darrell had access to, using today’s technology to search for any signs of buried remains or forensic evidence. 🌍🔬

However, no current evidence has surfaced that would support reopening or upgrading the case. It remains a mystery desperately needing a break. ❓🧱

💭 Theories and Speculation

When facts are limited, theories rush in to fill the vacuum. Here are some of the most commonly discussed ideas among internet sleuths and followers of the case:

1. 💀 Murder-Suicide Theory

Some believe Darrell murdered Terri and Nathan, possibly at the ranch, and then later took his own life out of guilt or fear of future consequences.

2. 🕵️‍♂️ Accomplice Involvement

Others wonder if someone helped Darrell hide the bodies. Could someone else on the ranch or in his circle know more than they've admitted?

3. 🚗 Planned Disappearance Theory

A smaller group believes Terri may have staged her disappearance to escape Darrell or the court proceedings. But this is widely dismissed—Terri left behind all her belongings and never contacted her family again, which was completely out of character. 🧳❌

🗣️ Public's Role in Cold Case Justice

Cold cases often get new life when the public stays engaged. Whether it’s through social media, tip lines, or investigative documentaries, community attention can keep pressure on law enforcement and draw out hidden truths. 📢👀

The Facebook page for Terri and Nathan is an example of how families turn grief into advocacy. By sharing their story, others may connect dots previously unseen. 🧩💬

If you know anything about the disappearance of Terri and Nathan Schlatter, please contact the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation or Wagoner County Sheriff's Office. Even the smallest tip could be the breakthrough this case needs. 🕵️‍♀️📞

🕯️ What the World Lost

Terri Schlatter was a mother, a daughter, a sister, and a friend. Nathan was an innocent baby, with an entire life ahead of him. Their absence left a hole in the lives of those who loved them. 💔👩‍👦

Every year that passes is another year of birthdays not celebrated, milestones missed, and justice unserved. 🗓️😢

And yet, the love of Terri’s family keeps her memory—and the search for answers—alive. 💖

🔚 Final Thoughts: A Legacy of Hope 🌅

Though decades have passed since that fateful March day in 1993, the mystery of Terri and Nathan Schlatter endures like a shadow cast over the Oklahoma landscape. 🏞️🕯️

For all the pain, there remains hope—hope that someone, somewhere, still holds a piece of the puzzle that could finally bring peace to a grieving family. ✝️🧩

In a world full of noise, silence can be deafening. But through community, persistence, and love, silence can be broken—and truth can rise. 🔦🕊️

🙏 If you or someone you know has information about this case, contact the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation at 1-800-522-8017 or visit www.osbi.ok.gov. 🙏

📱 And please consider following the Facebook page: Schlatter and Child Nathan Missing and Endangered to help keep the case in public view. 🧡