Justice for Julia: 72-Year-Old Arrested in 1991 St. Cloud Cold Case Murder

Florida Detectives Arrested 72 Year Old Alleged Murderer

Apr 22, 2025

Want to be a Citizen Detective? Get our PDF on investigating cold cases at home!

In a stunning turn of events that proves time is no barrier to justice, the St. Cloud Police Department has cracked a cold case that's haunted the quiet Florida community for more than three decades. On April 21, 2025, authorities announced the arrest of 72-year-old Stephen Daniel Smith for the 1991 stabbing death of 43-year-old Julia Sue Wilbanks.

This is more than an arrest. It’s a powerful message to families across the nation: justice delayed is not always justice denied. ⚖️💔

📅 The Crime That Shook St. Cloud

The date was October 4, 1991—just another day in the small Osceola County city, until the brutal murder of Julia Sue Wilbanks changed everything.

Julia, who was just 43 years old at the time, was found stabbed multiple times inside her duplex apartment. Police described the scene as violent, the result of a vicious and personal attack. There were signs of a struggle, but no suspect could be identified back then. The evidence was limited. DNA science was in its infancy. Witness accounts were unclear. The killer walked free 😢

The case eventually went cold, but the memory of Julia never did.

🧬 2025: DNA Brings the Past into the Present

Fast forward 34 years. Thanks to modern forensic technology and relentless investigative work, detectives were able to reopen the Wilbanks case and reprocess biological evidence found at the crime scene. What was once a dead end is now a direct match to Stephen Daniel Smith using advanced DNA testing and genealogy tools 🔬🧬

“This is a victory for justice and a moment of peace for Julia’s family,” said St. Cloud Police Chief Douglas Goerke in a press conference. “Our cold case team never gave up on her.” 🙏

👴 Who Is Stephen Daniel Smith?

Smith, now 72, was arrested without incident and charged with first-degree murder. He had no prior violent criminal convictions and had been living quietly in Florida all these years. But behind that quiet life, investigators now believe, was a dark secret that spanned over three decades 😨

At the time of Julia’s murder, Smith was acquainted with her through a mutual friend. It’s unclear what sparked the deadly altercation, but police say evidence at the time showed signs of forced entry and struggle, indicating an escalated personal encounter.

Thanks to genealogical DNA databases and new forensic technology, police were able to build a case that brought the long-cold file back into the spotlight 🔎🧓

📂 Cold Case Units: Fighting Time

This case is part of a broader wave of success from cold case units nationwide. In Florida alone, there are more than 15,000 unsolved murders dating back decades. But recent years have seen dramatic progress as local departments combine traditional detective work with modern science and even volunteer genealogists to crack cases once thought unsolvable.

The Wilbanks case is a textbook example of how cold case units can bring long-lost answers and closure to grieving families.

“These aren’t just files,” Chief Goerke said. “They’re people. They’re loved ones. We owe them everything we can give—even if it takes 30 years.” 📁💙

👩‍⚖️ What Happens Now?

Smith is currently being held in the Osceola County Jail and will face a bond hearing. Prosecutors are likely to pursue the case aggressively, given the violent nature of the murder and the overwhelming DNA evidence.

The case against Smith will likely include:

🧬 DNA evidence recovered at the scene and linked to him
🗣️ Possible witness statements from 1991 and beyond
📜 Timeline of his interactions with Wilbanks
📄 A documented lack of alibi and suspicious behavior

The defense may attempt to challenge the age of the evidence or Smith’s mental/physical state, but forensic experts and investigators say the science is solid.

💔 Remembering Julia Sue Wilbanks

Julia Sue Wilbanks wasn’t just a murder victim—she was a beloved member of the community, remembered by neighbors and family as kind-hearted, caring, and full of life 🌸

“She always made people feel welcome,” said one longtime friend. “Even if you were having a bad day, Julia would try to lift you up. Her murder shattered our world.”

For her family, this arrest brings both sorrow and closure. They now begin the painful process of re-living that terrible day—but this time, with answers.

“To everyone who never forgot my aunt Julia,” said her niece, “thank you. We finally have the start of justice. We finally have a name.” 🕊️💗

⚖️ A Pattern of Aging Killers Caught Late

In recent years, we’ve seen a pattern in cold case resolutions: older men finally being arrested decades after committing heinous crimes. The delay in justice isn’t from lack of effort, but from the slow pace of forensic advancements in the ‘80s and ‘90s.

Many of these individuals, like Smith, led seemingly quiet lives, blending into communities as if nothing had happened.

But no matter how many birthdays pass, the past catches up. And for Julia’s killer, the truth has arrived at last ⏳🧓🔒

🧠 Why Solving Cold Cases Matters

Cold cases are not just about catching criminals—they’re about:

Restoring dignity to victims 👼
Giving families answers and closure 🤲
Ensuring public trust in law enforcement 👮
Stopping potentially repeat offenders 🚨

Every solved case represents a victory over silence and a triumph of truth over time.

In Julia’s case, the power of DNA gave her a voice—one strong enough to echo through the decades and into a courtroom.

🙋 How You Can Help Solve Cold Cases

There are simple ways ordinary citizens can contribute to solving long-forgotten crimes:

🔁 Share cold case stories online to bring attention
🧬 Join or support genetic genealogy efforts
💸 Advocate for cold case funding in your state
☎️ Submit anonymous tips if you recall anything suspicious
🙋 Volunteer with organizations that aid law enforcement

You never know if one memory, one tip, or one post could be the missing link 🧩

🕯️ Final Words: Her Name Was Julia

Julia Sue Wilbanks was a woman who deserved far more time on this Earth. Though it took 34 years, the truth finally found its way forward. Her name is no longer part of a dusty file—it's a banner of resilience, a case that proves the justice system can still work, even after decades of waiting.

And for her family, this chapter—though painful—finally opens the door to peace.

✊ “Justice Is Coming for All of Them”

This case joins a growing list of recent cold cases cracked across Florida and the U.S. as investigators turn old files into fresh prosecutions. From Gainesville to Miami to Pensacola, families are starting to get answers once thought impossible.

As Chief Goerke boldly put it:
"We’re not done. Every victim deserves justice. And every killer should know—your time is running out." ⏰⚖️