Is There a Serial Killer in Western New York? Seems Suspicious
Some suspicious happenings are occurring in Western New York.
The Mysterious Disappearances in Lockport, East Amherst, and Broome County: Is There a Serial Killer on the Loose?
Want to be a Citizen Detective? Get our PDF on investigating cold cases at home!
🚨 A Wave of Disappearances Shakes New York Communities 🚨
In recent months, the towns of Lockport, East Amherst, and Broome County in New York have been gripped by a terrifying mystery. Several individuals have vanished, and some have been found dead under mysterious circumstances. 😨
The unsettling nature of these cases has led many to wonder: Is there a serial killer lurking in Western New York? Or is this a tragic coincidence? Let’s take a deep dive into what’s been happening, the fears of the community, and what authorities are doing to find answers. 🕵️♂️
💔 The Disappearance and Death of Danielle Hart 💔
On January 17, 2025, 44-year-old Danielle Hart was reported missing in Lockport, NY. Her family and friends were frantic, launching a massive search effort alongside local authorities. Volunteers scoured the area, posting flyers and knocking on doors, hoping for any clues about her whereabouts.
😢 Tragically, eight days later, Danielle’s body was found in a wooded area near Woodlands Mobile Home Park. The cause of death has not yet been determined, but investigators are treating it as a suspicious case.
👉 Community members were heartbroken, with many expressing their concerns online. “This isn’t just a random event. Something is going on here,” one local wrote on Facebook. 🖤
🌊 The Eerie Discovery of Leah Bellitto 🌊
Less than a month later, on February 13, 2025, another tragedy struck in the neighboring town of East Amherst, NY.
29-year-old Leah Bellitto had gone missing just days before. A desperate search was launched, and then, in a chilling discovery, her body was found in a creek. 👀
Disturbing details emerged from the scene: ✔️ Bare footprints were seen in the snow leading to the creek. ✔️ No immediate signs of foul play were found, but authorities remain puzzled. ✔️ The cause of death is still being determined.
❗ Many are questioning how two women in two nearby towns could both disappear and turn up dead in a matter of weeks. Could there be a link? ❗
🚨 A Pattern in Broome County? 🚨
Meanwhile, over in Broome County, a series of mysterious deaths has kept law enforcement on high alert. Two missing men were found dead in early February 2025 under suspicious circumstances. 😬
And this isn’t the first time this has happened...
🔍 Over the past few years, multiple women have been found dead near bodies of water in the area:
June 2022: A woman’s body was discovered in a creek near Ross Park. 😢
June 2022: Another body was found near the Rock Bottom Dam in the Susquehanna River.
May 2023: Yet another woman was found on the south bank of the Susquehanna River near a walking bridge.
👀 The similarities between these cases have fueled speculation that a serial killer may be targeting individuals in Broome County. But law enforcement has yet to confirm a direct link between these deaths.
🧩 Are These Cases Connected? 🧩
❓ Could all of these deaths and disappearances in Lockport, East Amherst, and Broome County be connected? ❓
Several common threads seem to be emerging:
✔️ Victims are disappearing and later being found dead.
✔️ Some bodies have been discovered near water.
✔️ There are no immediate signs of foul play in some cases, yet deaths remain unexplained.
✔️ Victims share similar age groups (20s-40s) and backgrounds.
Social media has been buzzing with theories. Many locals have pointed out that two women in Lockport and East Amherst were found dead within a month—and with the Broome County cases added into the mix, people are demanding answers. 🤯
A Facebook user posted: “We could have a serial killer in our backyard, and no one is talking about it.” 👀
🚔 What Are Law Enforcement Officials Saying? 🚔
While authorities acknowledge the public’s concern, they have not yet officially linked these cases together.
✔️ Lockport and East Amherst police are investigating their cases separately, but say they are keeping an open mindabout possible connections.
✔️ Broome County law enforcement has stated that while some cases are suspicious, there’s no solid proof of a serial killer at this time. 🕵️♂️
✔️ Authorities have urged residents to remain vigilant, be aware of their surroundings, and report anything suspicious. 🚨
But despite official statements, many in the community remain skeptical. People want answers.
🔦 Community Efforts & Calls for Action 🔦
As fear spreads, locals are stepping up to keep each other safe.
✔️ Volunteer groups have been organizing search parties and sharing updates on missing persons cases. 🙌
✔️ Social media groups dedicated to tracking these cases have gained thousands of members, sharing potential leads and safety tips.
✔️ Women’s self-defense classes have seen a surge in attendance, with more people wanting to learn how to protect themselves. 🥋
✔️ Residents are calling for increased police patrols and demanding more transparency from authorities.
🧠 Could This Be Another Serial Killer Case Like Altemio Sanchez? 🧠
This isn’t the first time New York has been haunted by a serial predator. One of the most infamous cases in the state’s history is that of Altemio Sanchez, the “Bike Path Killer”.
😱 Sanchez was responsible for a string of rapes and murders over three decades before he was finally caught in 2007. His crimes terrorized Buffalo and surrounding areas, and his ability to evade capture for years has left many wondering: Could history be repeating itself?
🚀 What’s Next? 🚀
👀 As investigations continue, residents of Lockport, East Amherst, and Broome County are demanding answers. The fear of a potential serial killer is causing unease, and the pressure is on law enforcement to connect the dots and bring closure to grieving families.
⚠️ Until more information is uncovered, the best thing you can do is stay aware, stay safe, and look out for one another.
💡 How You Can Stay Safe:
✔️ Always let someone know your whereabouts when heading out alone.
✔️ Stay in well-lit areas and avoid isolated locations at night.
✔️ If you feel unsafe, trust your instincts and seek help immediately.
✔️ Follow updates from official law enforcement channels and reliable news sources.
✔️ Report anything suspiciousto the authorities. 🚔
If you liked this article, you’ll love Inside The Mind of a Serial Killer.
Goood info. Hope they catch the killer !!!