Questions answered in this file

Why did police initially search the house?

Police entered the home executing a search warrant for evidence of a felonious assault. They were authorized to look for biological evidence, fingerprints, electronics, and a firearm recovered near Natalie Muscarello.

Why did the responding officers doubt the death was a suicide?

Officers noted that the firearm had been moved and lacked blood spatter. They also observed that the physical layout of the bedroom, including the distribution of biological matter, did not align with a suicide.

What did the autopsy reveal about the gunshot wound?

The coroner listed the range of fire as indeterminate. The autopsy report noted that there was no visible soot, unburned gunpowder, or stippling on the skin surrounding the wound, which are typically present in close-range firearm suicides.

What evidence was found inside the revolver?

Investigators found two spent cartridges inside the cylinder of the revolver. Official records do not explain why a second round was discharged.

What forensic tests were skipped during the investigation?

Police never submitted Natalie's gunshot residue swabs to the crime lab and did not test JayLon Johnson or other occupants for gunshot residue. Additionally, Johnson's clothing was never seized for analysis.